Monster Cookie Ninja Creami (35g of Protein!)

Fact: I’m a sucker for anything “monster cookie.” Between the cookie crumbles, the M&M’s, and the fun colors, it’s just one of those treat themes that are exciting to reach for (even as an adult!).

If you have a Ninja Creami ice cream machine (who doesn’t at this point?), you have to try this recipe! It’s not only fun to look at, but it’s packed with 35g of protein and contains a crunchy mix-in in every bite.

P.s. If you love Monster Cookie as much as I do, whip up a batch of our Monster Cookie Protein Bites to have on hand as a healthy, balanced snack. These are kiddo-approved, too!

3 Reasons Why You’ll Love This Creami Creation

1. It contains 35g of protein. Depending on which protein powder you use, you can count on there being about 35g of protein per pint in this Ninja Creami creation. Not a bad way to hit your protein goal if you ask me!
2. You’ll get a crunchy bit in every bite. One of the best part about making your own protein ice cream at home using your Ninja Creami machine is the ability to add in your favorite mix-ins! This recipe contains both crunchy cookies and M&Ms, ensuring you get a crunchy bit in every bite.
3. It’s a fun recipe. Sure, we might think of a kid when we think about “monster cookie” but adults deserve to have some fun, too!

MyFitnessPal & MacrosFirst Pre-Log

“FHM Monster Cookie Crunch Creami”

Dessert · Serves 1

Monster Cookie Ninja Creami

★★★★★Tap a star to rate

Full of bright, fun colors, 35g of protein, and a crunchy bit in every bite, this exciting Ninja Creami creation will quickly become one of your favorites.

Print Pin Rate

445 calories

35g protein

51g carbs

13g fat

30% protein · 45% carbs · 25% fat

7.9g protein per 100 cal

Prep

5 mins

Other

8 hrs

Total

8 hrs 5 mins

Ingredients

• 1 cup Fairlife white milk, low-fat
• 1 scoop vanilla protein powder (I recommend 1st Phorm Level-1 or Clean Simple Eats (code TAMI))
• 1 tsp Vanilla extract
• 1 tsp Blue food coloring
• 2 Chips Ahoy Thins cookies
• 2 tbsp Mini M&M's

Equipment

• Ninja Creami Ice Cream Machine
• Hand mixer or shaker bottle
• Measuring cups and spoons

Instructions

1. Add milk, vanilla extract, blue food coloring, and protein powder to your Creami container. Using a milk frother or blender, blend until smooth. Cover and freeze overnight, or at least 8 hours. Take your frozen base out of the freezer.

2. Run one cycle on lite ice cream.

3. Add a splash of milk *optional*, add 1 Chips Ahoy Cookie + 1 tbsp. Mini M&Ms.

4. Run the re-spin cycle until desired consistency.

5. Add remaining crumbled chips Ahoy Cookie + M&M’s to the top, mix in by hand, and enjoy!

Tami’s notes

This recipe is for the regular Ninja Creami pint size. If you have a Deluxe machine, multiply all ingredients by 1.5.

Feel free to use any color food coloring you wish or eliminate it all together.

Nutrition

Per serving (1full pint): Calories 445kcal · Protein 35g · Carbs 51g · Fat 13g

Nutrition is an estimate and will vary with the brands and amounts you use.